How it works
List It. Trade It. Own It.
List It
Create a free account and list something you own: raw cards, graded slabs, sealed product, minerals, watches and more, with photos, video, condition, grading and what you'd trade for.
Make an Offer
Found something you want? Build your offer on one screen: the item you want, the item you offer, the trading method and every fee. Counter, accept or decline in one place.
Agree & Complete
Both collectors accept the same terms and method. Pick your road: ship direct to each other, or send both items in to Gemmy for inspection and insured transfer. You ship, track and confirm receipt, and the trade completes.
Two ways to trade. Both collectors choose together.
Direct: ship straight to each other at your own risk. Gemmy doesn't inspect, authenticate or insure Direct trades, so review photos and disclosures and use tracked, insured shipping you buy yourself.
Send it in: both items go to Gemmy for inspection, an authentication review and a protected transfer. Coming soon.
Send It In: how shipping works
Coming SoonInsurance at declared value is included from the moment we receive your item until it reaches its new owner.
- 1Pack it right
Cards in a penny sleeve and semi-rigid holder or slab sleeve, sealed product in bubble wrap, all inside a sturdy box with no movement.
- 2Declare the value
Each item's declared value is locked in when both collectors accept. It sets the insurance amount.
- 3Ship with tracking
Use the prepaid insured label and the trade number Gemmy provides. No loose items, no notes inside the slab.
- 4Intake on arrival
Packages are opened on camera. Every item is photographed and matched to the accepted terms.
- 5Inspect and review
Condition is checked against the listing, and authenticity is reviewed. Problems pause the trade for both collectors.
- 6Insured return
Each item ships to its new owner, insured at declared value, with signature confirmation.